All abilities trek to the summit of Mount Kosciuszko - Australia's highest peak

All abilities trek to the summit of Mount Kosciuszko - Australia's highest peak
All abilities trek to the summit of Mount Kosciuszko - Australia's highest peak - © Jennifer Johnson 2008

Wednesday, December 7, 2011

Research is only good if it brings about improved access and accessible experiences - Lessons from Dunedin, New Zealand


This blog is dedicated to showcasing research evidence for accessible tourism. However, the overall aim is for the research to inform industry and government to improve accessible tourism experiences for people with disabilities. To this end we must all seek to influence the tourism policy agenda through presenting research based evidence and advocating for changes to practice where there has been a noted deficiency from the perspective of people with disabilities, suppliers or government regulators/coordinators.


I am currently at a research conference in Dunedin in New Zealand where any travel experience for a power wheelchair using quadriplegic with high support needs has its travel trip chain logistics that need to be organised before the rigours of an academic conference can be considered. Information planning, accommodation, air transport, ground transport, equipment hire, attendant services and medical supplies are just some of the considerations with organising an accessible trip. Luckily I had an insider's perspective at the destination to assist me with my travel planning through the University of Otago's Donna-Rose McKay who is the Manager of Disability Information & Support who was able to suggest a good quality accessible accommodation at the University of Otago - Executive Business Apartments. Further, Donna-Rose suggested I contact John Marrable, InformationConsultant at the Dunedin DisabilityInformation Service who provided contacts for hiring a patient lifter. The trip was finally confirmed once a direct flight from Sydney was negotiated with the only carrier providing direct service, my wife Fiona and my attendant Matt were ready to go.


Dunedin is located on the Otago Peninsula which is known for its ecotourism, historic architectural, cultural heritage and local cafe/bar experiences. Dunedin has much to offer the tourist looking for accessible experiences but finding travel planning information was not easy. Yet, local authorities are keen to improve on current practice and I met with the local disability information service, interested Dunedin Council representatives and local media. The following story - Benefits Seen in Accessible Tourism - appeared in the Otago Daily Times on 7 December 2011


http://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/189720/benefits-seen-accessible-tourism


What became evident was that while the urban town centre offered a good range of accessible opportunities for residents and tourists alike, the same could not be said for day trip operators in the region. Quite simply, outside of the excellent Taieri Gorge Railway we could not locate a single day to operator who could provide wheelchair access to any of the standard tours offered to other tourists. This is an extraordinary situation in a country that prides itself on its clean green image but obviously not one that is socially inclusive or sustainable. Accessible coaches and minibuses are not costly accessible tourism infrastructure and the Dunedin city bus fleet boasts an excellent fleet of low floor accessible buses. So what is the problem with the local tour operators? 


Photo 1: Simon Darcy boarding with the historic Taieri Gorge Railway carriage © Fiona Darcy 2011.




This situation has a significant cost disincentive for tourists with disabilities and seniors with access needs. For example, the magnificent Royal Albatross Colony at Taiaroa Head is a must see experience that has just made the Lonely Planet's 1000 Ultimate Sights, a standard tour to the colony with cost $95 per person. However, without access provision, the only option was to hire a Dunedin Taxi wheelchair accessible vehicle that cost $240 for the three-hour hire plus the $40 for the Royal Albatross Centre's Albatross Classic tour.


Do the figures - that is a $185 cost imposition on tourists with disabilities to have the same quality of experience as other tourists!


The other thing that tourists with disabilities miss out on by taking the "segregated" tourist experience is they don't get to mix socially with all the other tourists. This is something that all other tourists take for granted but is often lost where integrated day tour operations are not available. This in itself can significantly reduce the overall experience of the destination.


Sadly, this lack of accessibility to day trip operations is not isolated to New Zealand but is just as prevalent in Australia where "charter operations" have been excluded from the Disability Discrimination Act and the subsequent Disability Standards for Accessible Public Transport. This situation is currently being tested in the Federal Court of Australia where Julia Haraksin - a person with a disability - has challenged this exclusionary practice and hopefully this situation in Australia will be remedied in the near future. However, New Zealand does not have similar disability discrimination legislation and relies on the New Zealand Disability Strategy, which lacks opportunities for New Zealanders with disabilities to challenge discriminatory practices. 


While all this may seem daunting and overly critical, those of us who want to see improvements in accessible tourism experiences know the benefits of tourism are as important for people with disabilities as to the rest of the population. 


Photo 2: Simon Darcy enjoying time out from every day life, a spectacular view and a soaring Northern Royal Albatross some of the intangible social psychological benefits of tourism for all people © Fiona Darcy 2011.
Dunedin and the Otago Peninsula have much to offer people with disabilities and seniors with access needs, which could be made far more accessible through some basic improvements in information provision. However, a much broader commitment to the principles of accessible tourism and the desire of local tourism operators to provide accessible experiences for people with mobility, hearing, vision, intellectual, mental health and other disabilities is required. Given the increasing numbers of people with disabilities and seniors with access needs destinations need to make provisions in order to provide a competitive advantage in an increasingly competitive international tourism market (see Buhalis & Darcy 2011 and Buhalis, Darcy and Ambrose 2012).


References


  1. Buhalis, D., & Darcy, S. (Eds.). (2011). Accessible Tourism: Concepts and Issues. Bristol, UK: Channel View Publications.
  2. Buhalis, D., Darcy, S., & Ambrose, I. (Eds.). (2012). Best Practice in Accessible Tourism: Inclusion, Disability, Ageing Population and Tourism. Bristol, UK: Channel View Publications.
  3. Gibb, J. (2011, 7 December). Benefits seen in accessible tourism, Otago Daily Times. Retrieved from http://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/189720/benefits-seen-accessible-tourism


8 comments:

  1. This is a fantastic blog! some really great insight here guys!I agree that tourists feel segregated with disabilities and its not fair! I went on Hamburg City Breaks in Germany last year and I have to say had a great time! we were all treated equally!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi I am Bea Maximo, a blogger from the Philippines. I came across your blog as I was researching for my Thesis. I am currently a 4th Year BS Occupational Therapist Student of the University of Santo Tomas. Our thesis topic is about accessible tourism. I was hoping you could give us ideas on how to promote accessible tourism in the Philippines.

    Oh nice blog by the way. If you have time drop by my blog

    www.beamaX1mo.blogspot.com

    thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Bea Katrina

    In short, most countries have some good quality accessible infrastructure (transport, accommodation and attractions) and accessible destination experiences. However, what most do not do well is document the information accurately, to the level of detail required and disseminate it in accessible formats. Of course, this needs to recognise that there are different dimensions to access (mobility, hearing, vision and cognitive) and each of these groups has people with different levels of support needs (independent travellers through those who require assistance 24 hours). With that as a starting point you would have a foundation to directly target people with disability within a destination marketing programs.

    From a strategic perspective, the answer would be far more complex as each country has a different set of guiding principles to do with disability, discrimination, the building codes and attitudes to disability. While most countries have signed the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, most do not have disability discrimination legislation, do not have robust inclusions within building codes for the different dimensions of access and have not challenged attitudinal barriers to servicing the needs of people with disabilities. As such, a strong disability advocacy lobby together with legal challenges to discriminatory practices will slowly bring about change. In the interim, working with industry on improving their servicing of the group can bring about excellent case studies showing the importance of inclusion and the contribution towards the business case.

    Of course, you also need to get a copy of "Accessible Tourism: Concepts and Issues", together with the new book "BEST PRACTICE IN ACCESSIBLE TOURISM: Inclusion, Disability, Ageing Population and Tourism"!

    Good luck with completing your thesis and I would like to feature the executive summary on the blog when you have it completed.

    Simon

    ReplyDelete
  4. It’s great to see the things that are going on. Nice Post and thanks, for sharing.
    ---
    coffs harbour tourism

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for your kind comments Cheryl
    It is interesting that your sign off is from Coffs Harbour Tourism, as I was born in Coffs Harbour! I still have family links up that way but have not been up for about 7 years. We would be happy to work with you to develop a systematic approach to all things accessible tourism in Coffs Harbour. Let me know.

    Simon

    ReplyDelete
  6. wow, super in-depth article! Well done!
    This is an awesome guide
    Visit us:
    Wheelchair Taxi Melbourne

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi, This article is great. Thanks for sharing story.
    Sydney Minibus Hire

    ReplyDelete

Total Pageviews

There was an error in this gadget

Popular Posts

Labels